Major Tools
Other Tools
General Info

Issue #1423

2 issues with unsized x/z constants

Added by Udi Finkelstein 7 months ago. Updated 6 months ago.

% Done:



Verilator is complaining about this code snippet, even if SV mode:

module t1;
wire [63:0]x;
assign x = 'dx;

$ verilator --lint-only
%Error: Unsized X/Z/? not legal in decimal constant: x
%Error: Exiting due to 1 error(s)
%Error: Command Failed /home/udif/bin/verilator_bin --lint-only

This fails both as and t.v

But according to the quotes below, it is legal, even if not pretty.

In addition, the following code snippet:

module t2 ( output [287:0] o2);
assign o2 = 'hx;
Fails with:
$ verilator --lint-only -sv
%Warning-WIDTH: Operator ASSIGNW expects 288 bits on the Assign RHS, but Assign RHS's CONST '?32?bxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx' generates 32 bits.
%Warning-WIDTH: Use "/* verilator lint_off WIDTH */" and lint_on around source to disable this message.
%Error: Exiting due to 1 warning(s)
%Error: Command Failed /home/udif/bin/verilator_bin --lint-only -sv
In Verilog-1995, this indeed should be limited to 32 bits, but in SV, unsized constants should be expanded to any width. (From the little tests I've ran, Cadence simulators extends 'hx to 32 bits in 1995 mode, but then left pads with 0's to according to LHS width. In non 1995 mode, they sign extend to full LHS width).

References: =========== According to 5.7.1 in IEEE1800-2017:

If the size of the unsigned number is smaller than the size specified for the literal constant, the unsigned number shall be padded to the left with zeros. If the leftmost bit in the unsigned number is an x or a z, then an x or a z shall be used to pad to the left, respectively. If the size of the unsigned number is larger than the size specified for the literal constant, the unsigned number shall be truncated from the left.

The number of bits that make up an unsized number (which is a simple decimal number or a number with a base specifier but no size specification) shall be at least 32. Unsized unsigned literal constants where the high-order bit is unknown (X or x) or three-state (Z or z) shall be extended to the size of the expression containing the literal constant.

NOTEā€”In IEEE Std 1364-1995, in unsized literal constants where the high-order bit is unknown or three-state, the x or z was only extended to 32 bits.

So , according to this, in SV 'hx is expanded to any width, and in Verilog-95, it is extended to 32 bits only.

As for the usage of X/Z with 'd, here is part of the BNF from A.8.7 (same IEEE1800-2017 doc): (I dropped binary and octal BNF)

To summarize the BNF below, decimal numbers may be made of multiple decimal digits (no X/Z), but as a special case single digit x/z decimal constants are also allowed (both sized and unsized!) (with optional trailing underscores)

integral_number ::=
| octal_number
| binary_number
| hex_number

decimal_number ::=
| [ size ] decimal_base unsigned_number
| [ size ] decimal_base x_digit { _ }
| [ size ] decimal_base z_digit { _ }
unsigned_number ::= decimal_digit { _ | decimal_digit }
size ::= non_zero_unsigned_number
non_zero_unsigned_number ::= non_zero_decimal_digit { _ | decimal_digit}
decimal_base ::= '[s|S]d | '[s|S]D

hex_number ::= [ size ] hex_base hex_value
hex_base ::= '[s|S]h | '[s|S]H
hex_value ::= hex_digit { _ | hex_digit }
hex_digit ::= x_digit | z_digit | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | a | b | c | d | e | f | A | B | C | D | E | F
x_digit ::= x | X
z_digit ::= z | Z | ?


#1 Updated by Wilson Snyder 7 months ago

  • Category set to Unsupported
  • Status changed from New to Confirmed
  • Assignee set to Wilson Snyder

"'dx" was accidentally unsupported, fixed this in git towards 4.014.

The extension to match the spec I'll look at. I suspect there will still be a warning message, but the behavior if the warning is suppressed will change to match the spec.

As you note the best style is really to use "'x" instead.

#2 Updated by Wilson Snyder 7 months ago

  • Status changed from Confirmed to Resolved

X/Z extension fixed with warning in git towards 4.014.

#3 Updated by Wilson Snyder 6 months ago

  • Status changed from Resolved to Closed

In 4.014.

Also available in: Atom